Most organizations don’t struggle to announce a change. They struggle to make it stick. The memo goes out, there’s a launch meeting, and six months later people are quietly working the old way again.
John Kotter’s 8-step change model was written to deal with exactly that problem. It’s one of the best-known models in change management, and it turns up in almost every organizational behavior course. In this article we’ll go through the eight steps one at a time, work through an example, and then look at what the model does well and where it falls short.
Where Did Kotter’s Model Come From?
John Kotter is a long-time Harvard Business School professor who has written a great deal about leadership and change. In 1995 he published an article in Harvard Business Review called “Leading Change: Why Transformation Efforts Fail.” In it he said he’d watched more than 100 companies try to remake themselves over the previous decade, under labels like total quality management, reengineering, restructuring and cultural change.
Most of those efforts didn’t go as planned. So Kotter’s article was framed around the mistakes he kept seeing, such as not creating enough urgency, under-communicating the vision, and declaring victory too soon.
A year later, in his 1996 book Leading Change, he flipped those mistakes around into eight positive steps. That’s the version students usually learn.
It’s worth knowing that this wasn’t the first change model. Kurt Lewin’s much older unfreeze, change, refreeze model had already described change as a process with a beginning, a middle and an end. You can think of Kotter’s first four steps as a detailed version of “unfreezing,” steps five to seven as the “change,” and step eight as “refreezing.” Kotter just gives managers a lot more to do at each stage.
A Running Example: Merging Two Hospital Wards
This is a hypothetical example.
Imagine a regional hospital that decides to merge two medical wards, Ward 4 and Ward 6, into one 40-bed ward. Each ward has around 30 nursing staff. They have different rosters, different handover routines, and different ways of doing things that have built up over years. One nurse unit manager, Priya, will run the combined ward.
The hospital’s executives can see good reasons for the merger: shared specialist equipment, better cover for sick leave, and fewer agency nurses. But the nurses on the floor mostly see disruption. Who loses their preferred shifts? Whose handover process wins? Will anyone lose their job?
We’ll come back to Priya and her two wards at each step.
The Eight Steps
Step 1: Establish a Sense of Urgency
Kotter argued that the most common early mistake is letting people stay comfortable. If most staff believe things are fine as they are, they won’t put effort into something new.
Creating urgency doesn’t mean creating panic. It means helping people see the real problem or the real opportunity. For Priya, that might mean sharing the actual numbers on agency nurse costs, the shifts that went short-staffed last winter, and the patient delays that followed. Nurses tend to respond to evidence about patient care much more than to talk about budgets.
Step 2: Create a Guiding Coalition
No single manager can push a major change through on their own. Kotter’s second step is to pull together a group with enough position, credibility and skill to lead it.
In our hospital, a coalition made up only of executives would probably fail. So Priya might bring in respected senior nurses from both wards, someone from rostering, and a medical lead. The important point is that staff on both wards can see “one of their own” in the group. That makes it much harder for the merger to be seen as one ward taking over the other.
Step 3: Develop a Vision and Strategy
Next, the coalition needs a clear picture of where the change is heading and how it’ll get there. Kotter’s test was that you should be able to explain the vision in a few minutes and get a reaction that shows understanding and interest.
“Achieve operational synergies” won’t get that reaction from a nurse at 3am. Something like “one ward with enough staff on every shift, so nobody works short and patients don’t wait” is much more likely to.
Step 4: Communicate the Change Vision
Kotter said managers typically under-communicate the vision by a huge margin. One announcement email and a town hall isn’t enough, because people are flooded with other messages every day.
So Priya needs to repeat the vision often, in different places: handovers, team meetings, one-on-one conversations, the staff noticeboard. And she has to act consistently with it. If she says the merger is about patient care but then the first decision is to cut a shift, staff will believe the action, not the words.
Step 5: Empower Broad-Based Action
This step is about removing obstacles. Sometimes the obstacle is a system, sometimes a policy, and sometimes a person.
On the merged ward, obstacles might include two different electronic rostering setups, supply cupboards organized in two different ways, or a long-serving senior nurse who keeps telling junior staff “we’ll do it the Ward 4 way.” Priya’s job is to fix the systems and deal directly with anyone blocking the change. That might be a hard conversation, but leaving it alone tells everyone the change is optional.
This is also where a lot of resistance to change shows up, and it’s worth listening to it rather than just pushing through. Some objections will point to genuine problems with the plan.
Step 6: Generate Short-Term Wins
Big changes take a long time, and people lose faith if they see nothing improve for a year. Kotter recommended planning for visible wins early on, rather than just hoping they appear.
For Priya, an early win might be the first month where every shift was fully staffed without calling in agency nurses. Or a single shared handover sheet that both groups agree is better than either of the old ones. These wins need to be real and they need to be noticed, so she should share them and thank the people responsible.
Step 7: Consolidate Gains and Produce More Change
Here’s one of Kotter’s most useful warnings: don’t declare victory too soon. Once the first wins arrive, there’s a temptation to say the job is done and move on.
But if Priya relaxes six weeks in, the old habits from each ward can easily creep back. Instead, she should use the credibility from the early wins to tackle the harder issues, like aligning the two sets of clinical procedures or reworking the roster rules everyone complains about.
Step 8: Anchor New Approaches in the Culture
Finally, the change has to become “just how we do things here.” In other words, it needs to become part of the organization’s culture.
Kotter stressed two things at this stage. Show people how the new approach is linked to better results, and make sure the next generation of leaders actually believes in it. For Priya, that means telling new staff during orientation why the ward works the way it does, and choosing team leaders who support the merged approach rather than those who are nostalgic for the old wards.
Why Do Managers Like This Model?
The main reason is that it’s practical. Each step is something a manager can actually plan for and check off. That’s very different from a theory that only describes change from the outside.
It also puts people at the center. Five of the eight steps (urgency, coalition, communication, empowerment and short-term wins) are really about how employees think and feel about the change. That fits with what we know about why changes fail in the first place.
And it’s a useful diagnostic tool. If a change is stalling, a manager can go back through the steps and ask, “Which one did we skip?” Often it’s urgency or communication.
What Are the Limitations?
So should we treat Kotter’s model as proven? Not really.
The evidence base is thin. Kotter’s model came from his own observation and consulting experience, not from controlled research. In 2012, Appelbaum and colleagues reviewed 15 years of research looking for support for each step. They found support for most of the individual steps, but no formal studies that tested the whole model and its sequence. They suggested the model’s popularity comes more from how easy it is to use than from scientific agreement. They also found no evidence against it, and still recommended it as a planning tool alongside other approaches.
It’s very linear. Real change rarely moves neatly from step 1 to step 8. On Priya’s ward, the urgency might fade during a quiet summer and need rebuilding, while step 5 and step 6 happen at the same time. Kotter himself later moved away from a strictly sequential approach. His 2014 book Accelerate recast the steps as eight “accelerators” that run at the same time.
It’s quite top-down. The model mostly assumes senior people decide on the change and then bring everyone else along. That suits a planned merger, but it fits less well when change grows from the bottom up, or when staff should help decide whether the change is a good idea at all.
Urgency can be misused. If managers exaggerate a crisis to get people moving, they might get short-term action but lose trust. And the next time they say “this is urgent,” fewer people will believe them.
One more thing to be careful about. You’ll often read that “70% of change programs fail,” usually alongside Kotter’s model. Hughes (2011) went looking for the evidence behind that figure and found no valid, reliable empirical basis for it. So it’s best not to repeat it in an essay as if it were fact.
What Does This Mean for Managers?
If you’re a team leader about to run a change, Kotter’s steps make a good checklist. Before you announce anything, ask yourself: Do people actually see why this matters? Who’s helping me lead it? Can I explain the vision in a sentence or two? What’s going to get in the way? What will an early win look like?
But use it as a guide, not a script. Go back to earlier steps when you need to, listen to the people pushing back, and adjust the plan for your own workplace. A small change to a meeting process doesn’t need all eight steps. A ward merger probably does.
Key Points to Take Away
- John Kotter introduced his eight steps in his 1995 Harvard Business Review article on why transformation efforts fail, and set them out fully in his 1996 book Leading Change.
- The eight steps are: establish urgency, create a guiding coalition, develop a vision and strategy, communicate the vision, empower broad-based action, generate short-term wins, consolidate gains and produce more change, and anchor new approaches in the culture.
- The model builds on Lewin’s earlier unfreeze, change, refreeze idea, but gives managers much more detail on what to do.
- Its strengths are that it’s practical, people-focused and easy to use as a checklist.
- Its weaknesses are a limited evidence base for the model as a whole, a linear structure that real change rarely follows, and a top-down view of change.
- Kotter later reworked the steps into eight “accelerators” that run at the same time (Accelerate, 2014).
Sources
- Kotter, J. P. (1995). Leading Change: Why Transformation Efforts Fail. Harvard Business Review, March-April 1995.
- Appelbaum, S. H., Habashy, S., Malo, J.-L. and Shafiq, H. (2012). Back to the Future: Revisiting Kotter’s 1996 Change Model. Journal of Management Development, 31(8), 764-782.
- Hughes, M. (2011). Do 70 Per Cent of All Organizational Change Initiatives Really Fail? Journal of Change Management, 11(4), 451-464.
- Kotter Inc. The 8 Steps for Leading Change.
